NetReserve by NetSimR

Reserving Report

Generated 18 November 2026, 20:03

Key results

Simulated motor: paid and incurred claims, premiums: 12 origins, 12 development periods.

Latest
69,294,594
Selected ultimate
84,313,138
Loss ratio 70.0%
Selected IBNR
15,018,544
Chain ladder IBNR
15,018,544
Mack standard error 967,470, CV 6.4%
One-year standard error
734,605
Merz-Wüthrich
Bootstrap 99.5%
17,456,496
Mean 15,032,506

Data and settings

Data
Source
Simulated motor: paid and incurred claims, premiums
Origins
2014 to 2025
Development periods
12
Premiums
120,431,000
Incurred claims
Yes
Development
Average
Volume-weighted
Calendar periods
All
Link ratios left out
0
Tail
None
Single link ratio sigma
Log-linear
Ultimates
Methods
12 Chain ladder
Cape Cod decay
1
Cape Cod loss ratio
69.7%

Development factors

Factors

Factor Selected To ultimate Link ratios used
1-2 1.8866 3.3372 11
2-3 1.2799 1.7689 10
3-4 1.1411 1.3821 9
4-5 1.0754 1.2112 8
5-6 1.0508 1.1263 7
6-7 1.0280 1.0718 6
7-8 1.0170 1.0426 5
8-9 1.0111 1.0252 4
9-10 1.0114 1.0139 3
10-11 1.0011 1.0025 2
11-12 1.0014 1.0014 1
Tail 1.0000 1.0000

Averages: volume-weighted. Sigma of 11-12 (a single link ratio) extrapolated log-linearly.

Tail factors compared

Tail Tail factor Chain ladder IBNR
No tail 1.0000 15,018,544
Exponential curve, from factor 1 1.0017 15,159,683
Inverse power curve, from factor 1 1.0225 16,914,234
Clark log-logistic 1.1361 26,489,498
Clark Weibull 1.0141 16,204,327

The tail each curve gives beyond the last development period, with the chain ladder's IBNR.

Development

Each line is an origin, from the oldest (lightest) to the latest (darkest).

Cumulative claims by development period Cumulative claims by development period

Link ratios

Link ratios with the selected factors Link ratios with the selected factors

Ultimates

By origin

Origin Latest Developed Chain ladder BF Benktander Cape Cod Selected Ultimate IBNR Loss ratio
2014 5,322,407 100.0% 5,322,407 5,322,407 5,322,407 5,322,407 Chain ladder 5,322,407 0 65.3%
2015 5,743,751 99.9% 5,752,006 5,752,118 5,752,006 5,752,083 Chain ladder 5,752,006 8,255 69.1%
2016 6,457,627 99.7% 6,473,957 6,473,264 6,473,955 6,473,200 Chain ladder 6,473,957 16,330 73.1%
2017 6,930,336 98.6% 7,026,956 7,020,320 7,026,865 7,019,949 Chain ladder 7,026,956 96,620 75.2%
2018 5,865,110 97.5% 6,013,065 6,028,118 6,013,436 6,027,446 Chain ladder 6,013,065 147,955 63.5%
2019 6,621,118 95.9% 6,903,429 6,898,390 6,903,223 6,897,247 Chain ladder 6,903,429 282,311 71.3%
2020 5,908,704 93.3% 6,332,839 6,388,960 6,336,597 6,386,981 Chain ladder 6,332,839 424,135 61.8%
2021 7,639,503 88.8% 8,604,127 8,463,681 8,588,381 8,460,284 Chain ladder 8,604,127 964,624 81.9%
2022 5,615,887 82.6% 6,801,772 6,938,362 6,825,587 6,932,912 Chain ladder 6,801,772 1,185,885 62.8%
2023 5,290,187 72.4% 7,311,556 7,540,672 7,374,898 7,531,398 Chain ladder 7,311,556 2,021,369 62.9%
2024 5,479,114 56.5% 9,692,085 9,039,765 9,408,533 9,025,090 Chain ladder 9,692,085 4,212,971 82.8%
2025 2,420,850 30.0% 8,078,939 8,148,877 8,127,920 8,125,270 Chain ladder 8,078,939 5,658,089 69.1%
Total 69,294,594 82.2% 84,313,138 84,014,934 84,153,808 83,954,267 84,313,138 15,018,544 70.0%

BF: Bornhuetter-Ferguson. The selected method of each origin gives its ultimate. The Cape Cod loss ratio is 69.7%.

Ultimates by origin

Latest claims and IBNR of each origin, with the ultimate of each method Latest claims and IBNR of each origin, with the ultimate of each method

Uncertainty

Mack's standard errors

Origin IBNR Standard error CV Process Parameter
2014 0 0 — 0 0
2015 8,255 11,127 134.8% 7,714 8,019
2016 16,330 14,387 88.1% 10,195 10,152
2017 96,620 72,113 74.6% 60,489 39,261
2018 147,955 69,857 47.2% 60,244 35,364
2019 282,311 81,161 28.7% 69,257 42,315
2020 424,135 100,910 23.8% 89,768 46,094
2021 964,624 142,015 14.7% 124,003 69,221
2022 1,185,885 162,191 13.7% 148,426 65,387
2023 2,021,369 206,568 10.2% 190,228 80,523
2024 4,212,971 431,007 10.2% 397,873 165,723
2025 5,658,089 621,112 11.0% 586,690 203,902
Total 15,018,544 967,470 6.4% 772,274 582,743

Of the chain ladder: the process and parameter parts of the standard error.

One-year view

Origin One-year standard error Until ultimate
2014 0 0
2015 11,127 11,127
2016 10,044 14,387
2017 70,890 72,113
2018 31,001 69,857
2019 35,390 81,161
2020 68,575 100,910
2021 79,057 142,015
2022 108,811 162,191
2023 122,512 206,568
2024 358,317 431,007
2025 487,383 621,112
Total 734,605 967,470

Merz and Wüthrich: how much the ultimate can move over the next year.

Bootstrap

Origin Mean IBNR Standard deviation 75% 90% 95% 99% 99.5%
2014 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
2015 7,990 18,515 14,283 30,001 41,824 71,217 84,036
2016 15,822 25,409 28,686 47,709 61,924 94,181 105,556
2017 96,432 50,780 126,442 164,202 187,452 237,917 255,372
2018 147,423 58,341 182,090 223,601 251,495 309,859 330,504
2019 281,389 82,916 331,649 389,565 426,012 505,065 531,298
2020 424,077 98,826 487,506 555,390 595,071 675,942 706,148
2021 963,224 153,590 1,061,691 1,160,931 1,223,248 1,364,962 1,429,483
2022 1,191,325 166,719 1,300,250 1,409,018 1,474,707 1,607,183 1,672,024
2023 2,021,724 232,963 2,174,187 2,325,544 2,409,737 2,583,462 2,630,758
2024 4,220,049 382,967 4,478,046 4,716,510 4,867,494 5,140,383 5,249,812
2025 5,663,051 595,749 6,069,517 6,436,469 6,639,987 7,064,828 7,197,376
Total 15,032,506 926,951 15,652,033 16,230,087 16,535,075 17,203,400 17,456,496

Bootstrap chain ladder (gamma process, 5,000 simulations), 5,000 simulations.

Distribution of the total IBNR

Distribution of the simulated total IBNR Distribution of the simulated total IBNR

IFRS 17 and Solvency II

Best estimate
14,093,274
Discounted from 15,018,544; mean term 2.06 years
Risk adjustment
581,359
Percentile; confidence level 75.0%
Liability for incurred claims
14,674,633
Reserve risk (Solvency II)
3,805,184
Segment 1, standard deviation 9.0%

Discounted reserves

Origin Reserve Discounted Discount
2014 0 0 0
2015 8,255 8,133 121
2016 16,330 15,817 513
2017 96,620 94,374 2,246
2018 147,955 142,621 5,334
2019 282,311 269,416 12,895
2020 424,135 402,032 22,103
2021 964,624 911,394 53,230
2022 1,185,885 1,114,566 71,320
2023 2,021,369 1,895,409 125,960
2024 4,212,971 3,943,098 269,872
2025 5,658,089 5,296,413 361,676
Total 15,018,544 14,093,274 925,270

Spot rates 3.00, 3.10, 3.20, 3.30, 3.40% for 1, 2, 3, ... years; payments mid-period of each period of 1 years.

Cash flows

Future payments and their present value Future payments and their present value

More methods

Actual vs expected, latest period

Origin Expected Actual Actual / expected z
2014 — 7,638 — —
2015 10,552 2,292 22% -0.33
2016 73,861 70,738 96% -0.031
2017 70,494 90,235 128% 0.63
2018 97,916 98,054 100% 0.0047
2019 153,218 285,080 186% 3.9
2020 290,745 264,490 91% -0.42
2021 561,657 445,225 79% -1.1
2022 693,113 699,512 101% 0.063
2023 1,226,081 1,001,064 82% -1
2024 2,414,826 2,714,510 112% 1
2025 — — — —
Total 5,592,464 5,671,200 101% 0.19

z beyond about 2 either way is worth a look.

Other methods

Method IBNR Standard error
Chain ladder 15,018,544 967,470
Clark Clark LDF method, log-logistic curve 29,458,751 2,580,277
Chain ladder with claims inflation 15,018,544 —

Paid and incurred

Munich chain ladder

Origin CL paid CL incurred Munich paid Munich incurred
2014 5,322,407 5,328,268 5,322,407 5,328,268
2015 5,752,006 5,759,629 5,753,192 5,758,214
2016 6,473,957 6,470,979 6,457,649 6,490,285
2017 7,026,956 7,028,262 7,020,339 7,035,382
2018 6,013,065 5,999,685 6,010,117 6,000,869
2019 6,903,429 6,925,275 6,901,780 6,926,455
2020 6,332,839 6,407,393 6,355,537 6,388,312
2021 8,604,127 8,596,618 8,589,386 8,610,707
2022 6,801,772 6,882,265 6,830,303 6,855,349
2023 7,311,556 7,441,385 7,361,421 7,388,955
2024 9,692,085 9,563,432 9,613,093 9,637,418
2025 8,078,939 9,248,129 8,668,084 8,715,947
Total 84,313,138 85,651,321 84,883,308 85,136,161

The ultimates of paid and incurred claims projected together.

How to read this report

  • The IBNR is the ultimate less the latest claims: for paid claims it includes the case reserves.
  • Mack's standard error measures the uncertainty of the chain ladder until the claims are all paid; the one-year standard error, the part that can emerge over the next year.
  • The bootstrap simulates the reserves, so its percentiles, such as 99.5%, give the reserve risk directly.
  • Figures follow the choices of the tool when the report was made: the factors, the tail and each origin's method.