
Rate reviews: on-level premiums, the indicated rate change and credibility
Source:vignettes/PricingMonitoring.Rmd
PricingMonitoring.RmdA rate review asks whether the current rates will pay for next year’s claims. This vignette works through the loss ratio method with NetSimR: the past premiums brought to today’s rates, the past losses brought to next year’s cost, and the indicated change, with credibility for the segments that have little data of their own.
Premiums at today’s rates
The premium a year earned was charged at the rates of its policies.
Rates rose 5% in July 2021, fell 2% in January 2023 and rose 8% in April
2024; with annual policies written evenly through the year, the premium
of each calendar year mixes the rates of two years of writing.
on_level_premium() works out each year’s average rate
level, the parallelogram method, and the factor that brings its premium
to today’s rates:
changes <- data.frame(date = as.Date(c("2021-07-01", "2023-01-01", "2024-04-01")),
change = c(0.05, -0.02, 0.08))
onl <- on_level_premium(premium = c(9.2e6, 9.8e6, 10.4e6, 11.1e6), years = 2021:2024, changes)
onl## year premium average_level on_level_factor on_level_premium
## 1 2021 9200000 1.006353 1.104304 10159598
## 2 2022 9800000 1.043852 1.064633 10433407
## 3 2023 10400000 1.039500 1.069091 11118545
## 4 2024 11100000 1.052237 1.056150 11723265
The indicated rate change
The ultimate losses of each year, from a reserving method such as the chain ladder, are trended at 4% a year to the claims of the policies the new rates will price: rates taking effect in January 2026 for a year, on annual policies, whose average claim date is the start of 2027. The experience loss ratio is compared with the permissible loss ratio, which leaves 27% of the premium for expenses and 5% for profit:
rate <- indicated_rate_change(losses = c(6.3e6, 6.6e6, 7.4e6, 7.6e6), premium = onl$on_level_premium,
years = 2021:2024, trend = 0.04, effective = as.Date("2026-01-01"),
expense_ratio = 0.27, profit = 0.05)
rate$by_year## year losses trend_factor trended_losses premium loss_ratio
## 1 2021 6300000 1.240747 7816708 10159598 0.7693915
## 2 2022 6600000 1.193026 7873974 10433407 0.7546886
## 3 2023 7400000 1.147141 8488841 11118545 0.7634849
## 4 2024 7600000 1.103020 8382951 11723265 0.7150697
c(experience = rate$experience_loss_ratio, permissible = rate$permissible_loss_ratio,
indicated_change = rate$indicated_change)## experience permissible indicated_change
## 0.7496860 0.6800000 0.1024795
A small portfolio’s experience is not fully credible: with
credibility below 1, its loss ratio is blended with a
complement, such as the loss ratio the current rates assume
(credibility_weight() gives the limited fluctuation
credibility of a number of claims).
Credibility between segments
Schemes, fleets or regions each have their own experience, more or less of it. Buhlmann-Straub credibility gives each one’s estimate as its own mean shrunk towards the collective, the more so the less premium it has and the less the segments differ:
set.seed(1)
schemes <- data.frame(scheme = rep(c("A", "B", "C", "D", "E"), each = 4),
premium = round(runif(20, 1e5, 1.5e6)))
true <- c(A = 0.55, B = 0.62, C = 0.66, D = 0.75, E = 0.60)[schemes$scheme]
schemes$loss_ratio <- rgamma(20, shape = schemes$premium / 1e4, rate = schemes$premium / 1e4 / true)
bs <- buhlmann_straub(schemes$loss_ratio, schemes$premium, schemes$scheme)
bs$by_group## group weight periods mean credibility estimate
## 1 A 3366171 4 0.5544676 0.8470481 0.5661548
## 2 B 4187763 4 0.6253037 0.8732521 0.6260103
## 3 C 1902804 4 0.6620445 0.7578974 0.6544991
## 4 D 3674134 4 0.7512478 0.8580485 0.7341612
## 5 E 4413807 4 0.5656745 0.8789576 0.5735670
The scheme with the least premium gets the least credibility, and its
estimate moves furthest towards the collective loss ratio of 63.1%. The
results match those of the actuar package’s cm().